In the days following September 1th, 2001, my personal philosophies were still smarting with the pain of the attacks. With the kind of clarity that only vengefulness can produce, I began to think about issues surrounding our interrogation techniques of those detained in connection with the attacks, no matter how remote their links.
As a moral relativist, particularly with three thousand no-longer-hypothetical corpses weighing on the balance, it seemed to me that the use or threat of torture with specific detainees would be justified. After all, if one person held the key to saving the lives of thousands, and extreme methods may reveal that information to us, why shouldn't we suspend that person's rights for the greater good? And, why then couldn't we extend that thinking to small groups/cells of bad guys? You place a higher value on the rights of five non-citizens than on the rights of their thousands of potential victims?
As the shock wore off, my thoughts matured to consider the futility of such a distinction and how self-destructive such a course could be. The Bush administration helped me by very publicly blurring the lines between terrorists, enemy combatants, lawful detainees, material witnesses, and myriad other questionable classifications. Their Patriot Act tore out 50% of the pages from my law school constitutional studies texts with brazenness we could not have imagined. Each action taken drew these issues from the academic realm into unavoidable and stinging presence.
Now as our eyes are seared by the images of men and women tortured in American custody, any shred of me clinging to the idea that there were justified uses of violence and physical coercion now feels like a betrayal of democracy. Relativism has no place in the sphere of human rights. I feel weak that I needed such graphic imagery and horrible testimony to fully conclude this, but I now have no doubt at all.
Take a minute to read this article from Slate detailing a chronology of self-serving statements by the administration concerning Saddam's torture, and our disgusting emulation of his worst.
We all must ensure this never happens again.