Not So Clear For Me.

My friend Brad Feld recently posted a ringing endorsement for Clear, a company contracting with the TSA and individual airports to offer accelerated passage through security check lines. Essentially, for $100 a year(after a pre-screening that costs an additional $28), the Clear program employees escort participating travelers to the front of the security line. As I still find myself flying once or twice a week, I can sympathize with Brad's assessment that paying a mere $100 to skip the line maze is worth it considering the value of the aggregate time saved.

If the hundred bucks were all I was conferring to Clear in exchange for this privilege, I would not hesitate to sign up. Yet, after learning more about the program, I became concerned. You see, to qualify for Clear, a candidate needs to first provide some biographical data including a social security number, home addresses for the past five years, and a current credit card. If accepted, then this potential new customer needs to pay an in-person visit to a Clear station in which they 1) provide two forms of government-issued identification, 2) have their picture taken, 3) produce fingerprints, and then 4) submit to an iris scan.

Wow. If we join, remind me what we get in return for providing all of that data? Do we get to skip the metal detectors and xray machines? Do I no longer have to take my laptop out of the bag? Hopefully, I can now bring on fluids of normal size?

Nope. A Clear membership just entitles you to move to the front of the herd that is waiting to be moved through the futile theater that is our current security screening program. All Clear participants are still required be screened as thoroughly as any other passenger. Clear solely moves you to the head of the line.

 

So, why could Clear and, presumably, TSA want all of this background information? What bearing could any of this history or biometric data possibly have on whether I am fit to stand at the front of the line for the security check?

Reading the fine print of Clear's privacy policies, I learned that the social security number is not actually required and the credit card is just used for their billing purposes and neither are shared with TSA. I particularly enjoy what great lengths to which they go to explain how they protect such information when, in the next section, they discuss the process by which they ship everything else directly to TSA to let the sanctioned invasion begin:

"The TSA makes the necessary security threat assessment that will determine if the applicant is cleared for membership in the program. TSA makes this Threat Assessment using a variety of terrorist  threat-related databases. TSA does not transmit to Clear or to the airport any information about the applicant or any reasons for its decisions.  [Clear's emphasis] TSA tells us only that the applicant, having gone through the TSA threat assessment process, has received either an "Approved Security Threat Assessment" or has received a "Not Approved Security Threat Assessment."

Thus, if I am determined to be a national security threat, the way I am dealt with is by denying me a Clear card and thereby forcing me to spend more time in line? Not so fast. It seems I would first get a chance to appeal the unbearable consequences of being forced to wait in line:

"The TSA's policy is that it will establish an adjudication process for those who are denied enrollment and wish to question that decision. However, the nature and effectiveness of that process is beyond Clear's control."

I do have to hand it to Clear in that last sentence. They certainly seem to illustrate a solid understanding of the agency and political administration with whom they are dealing.

All told, I just don't see the risk/reward playing out in favor of joining Clear. Though I am certain there is already some dissident file on me within the government bowels, I am not exactly racing to ensure its completeness by paying for the privilege of voluntarily populating their databases with my biometric data. Instead, I would much rather the government stick to its time-tested techniques of otherwise taking it all by deceptive means or forcibly compelling its production. 

In the meantime, I will tip my hat to Clear's founder, Stephen Brill, the founder of that venerable American institution CourtTV, and the 85,000 brave, patriotic souls who have elected to participate in this noble program because, as we know, if we wait in line, we have let the terrorists win.

Comments

[Aziz]

Clear is offering a partial solution to the real problem, TSA.

TSA has received billions since 911, yet, they've never caught a threat, ever. The upper-level managers have, however, been caught stealing upwards of $500,000, and their staff in the airports have been caught stealing upwards of $150,000 from travelers belongings. Let's not forget that the incompetency of the 1 hour security process has made passengers miss flights, bags miss destinations, and airlines to lose valuable time.

TSA has done one thing. They've given airports a lot more money through beverage sales taxes, since none of us can take a bottle of water with us for a 5 hour flight.

Clear isn't the answer, and the business model is pretty much the same as holding a platinum A-mex, and that's free. (Delta A-mex and Platinum and above A-mex holders go to front of the line). That's really where Clear's idea is coming from. I had thought that a nice service would be a drop box and delivery service at airports, supported and run by airlines. That way you wouldn't have to throw away something you accidentally packed that the TSA wouldn't allow you to take on the plane.

Two Cents

[Aziz]

I forgot to add that TSA has failed 11 out of 12 or so attempts to catch unlawful carry-ons by people paid to test security, and I'm pretty sure that the one person that they caught was a young person that bragged about it in a blog that reached their ears.

[Chester]

Very nice. For a mere $28 and $100/year, one gets the privilege of buying into a shamelessly commercial product of counter-productive Bush Administration alarmism and earn the enmity of all the "little people" in front of whom one cuts in line. What a bargain.

[Marc J. Randazza]

I agree with all of your reasons for hating on CLEAR. Plus, I'm pleased to see as few people as possible pick up one of the little cards. However, I succumbed.

I travel a lot, and I live in Orlando, Florida. If you ever use MCO, you'll know that it is home the the most prole-infused flying class you'll ever see. Absolute fucking morons who will try and carry a suit of armor through the metal detector. Getting in front of one pathetic midwestern family can save you 20 minutes.

The second reason I can't live without my CLEAR card is that, well, to put it simply, I look sketchy. My Sicilian ancestors picked up a lot of genes from the 700 year period during which the Saracens ruled that island. I get "randomly" selected a hell of a lot. CLEAR ensures that the rednecks can't "randomly" select me at a CLEAR airport -- that's pretty sweet when you look like half a muslim (in the eyes of the white trash that staff the TSA stands in Florida).

I admire your willingness to stand in line. I just can't stand it. CLEAR lets you choose to either get a retina scan OR a fingerprint -- and since I'm already fingerprinted by about 10 government agencies, that wasn;t much of a surrender.

[buy cialis]

Reading the fine print of Clear's privacy policies, I learned that the social security number is not actually required and the credit card is just used for their billing purposes and neither are shared with TSA. I particularly enjoy what great lengths to which they go to explain how they protect such information when, in the next section, they discuss the process by which they ship everything else directly to TSA to let the sanctioned invasion begin:

[Chanel Jewelry]

Above all that, when you are doing other Coach Bags there are different women’s UGG Boots on sale for various occasions. Let’s say you can have the classic ghd Hair Straighteners or neutral shaded pump for formal wear, strappy sandals or sexy MBT Shoes for the evening out, casual Chanel Jewelry that go best with your jeans and beach Ray Ban Sunglasses.

[miu miu bags]

Great post!
Replica miu miu handbags are not just beautiful and elegant, but it is also at excellent quality and similar design as the real. You will like it once you see it. Now attention please, at our shop, we are holding a promotion. You can buy replica miu miu bags of high quality with the lowest price. Meanwhile, miu miu handbags buying from here you can enjoy free and fast delivery shipping. Welcome to our shop!

[abercrombie and fitch uk]

Well said, such a person should be a good sentence, or the future will be more rampant.

[abercrombie & fitch london]

I read this sentence out loud to a group of engineers from my team at lunch the other day and they cracked up like I did. It touched off such a wave of nostalgia for the first machines we all used and when we first discovered the Internet. We all felt so old and yet so lucky.

[ed hardy uk]

I agree with all of your reasons for hating on CLEAR.

[ed hardy outlet]

I read this sentence out loud to a group of engineers from my team at lunch the other day and they cracked up like I did.

[abercrombie]

Notice that the Chinese know how to do a stimulus package, while no one in power seems to know how to do a stimulus package here in the US.

[abercrombie]

I will never forget my oncologist telling me that I had to change my life in order to live.

[Abercrombie outlet]

I hate guns If no guns of everyone,the world maybe well.Abercrombie outlet

[Jordan 8]

Count your age with friends but not with years. Good luck to you!!

[Nike Dunk Sb]

Thank your for display me so fantastic notion as part of your blog. I am really gree with you. Your viewpoint is amazing. In our lives, there's nothing can beat us.

[nike shox]

Thanks for sharing how blogging has impacted you! I want to be in your class! I teach 3rd grade and have a few students who have blogs. They struggle with feeling like they have an audience. What is your secret in getting the word out about your blog?

[hollister clothing]

Caution to readers: do not confuse the tactics of a rookie like Saddam with an experienced gesticulator like11

[abercrombie milano]

Love is a feeling, not only on the material to meet, but also to the spiritual care and stick
aa

[New Balance 574]

You have inspired me to adapt this project for my high school level design class.

[vibram.us]

Seventh, you tell me that, "remember to send my next Tanabata gift!"
I raise head, "why? You should give me!"
You touch my head to say "Chinese valentine's day, you're not my lover..."
I never valentine's day, but that day, I was accidentally Vibram Fivefingers Shoes / nattierblue grey sprint shoesare looking forward to next valentine's day, because you want me to send you a gift, is my illusion or you unintentionally, why I see your eyes are expecting? Perhaps you have started from a very clear told me we not lovers!

[ugg outlet]

The best cure for the national economy would beeconomy.

[air yeezy]

People also tend to mix truth and error to teach people, and insist it is wrong.

[cheap jordans]

Excellent post, thank you very much for taking the time to share with those who are starting on the subject. Greetings

[Kamagra]

Hey,

Great post, please continue sharing to us !!

Thanks **

[Remeron]

This is a great idea, I would like to read this information every day
Thanks for sharing

[Astrology Readings]

I need a good compliment for each person but I also need a list of one word complements and the teacher is going to check them (sadly enough) examples: nice, smart, funny, brave, outgoing, etc.